Social solidarity plays a vital role in coping after tragedies

20 Dec 2012

Community solidarity and support have remarkable benefits for communities coping with traumatic mass shootings, according to an American-Finnish research study recently published by the University of Turku.

James Hawdon and John Ryan, both professors of sociology at Virginia Tech, and Finnish researchers Atte Oksanen and Pekka Räsänen investigated the responses of four communities that suffered from similar tragedies in the United States and Finland.

People in all four communities expressed their need for belonging after the shootings, and this solidarity appeared to have remarkable benefits for their well-being both in everyday life and after stressful life events. The study, published Oct. 30, compared responses to tragedies at a shopping mall in Omaha, Neb., and at schools in Jokela and Kauhajoki, Finland, and Blacksburg, Va.

After each of these incidents, the afflicted community responded with displays of solidarity. Mass gatherings, communal vigils, spontaneously erected monuments to the victims all demonstrated that the community was in shock yet united, the researchers said. The residents gathered to express their collective grief, and the intense rituals focused their attention on their collective loss and on each other.

While there were similarities in how the communities responded to the tragedies, there were also differences. Community response was more evident in the United States, and the state, the media, and residents played an active role in promoting solidarity. In Finland, however, it appeared that neither the state nor the media emphasized informal social support generated by community solidarity.

The reliance on state-sponsored crisis counseling and the media’s tendency to focus their stories primarily on the shooters rather than the victims or communities may have hindered the emergence of a beneficial solidarity and instead contributed to the emergence of a more stigmatizing solidarity.

Researchers say people assisting communities after tragedies should be careful not to let efforts to provide counseling interfere with the community’s activities. Based on the team’s research, participating in the activities of local businesses, religious establishments, voluntary organizations, and social clubs shortly after a tragedy promoted solidarity but seeing a crises counselor reduced solidarity.

Ryan is a professor and chair of the department of sociology, and Hawdon is a sociology professor and the director of the Center for Peace Studies and Violence Prevention at Virginia Tech. Oksanen is a senior researcher at the Finnish Youth Research Society. Räsänen is a professor of economic sociology at the University of Turku, Finland.